Builder in a hard hat inspecting the timber frame of a new house
Strategic Insights

Before the tax benefit: testing the builder behind a new-build investment

The tax benefit on a new dwelling is only worth something once the builder finishes the home, a tenant moves in and the lender values it. Before signing, test the builder, the contract terms, the build time and the value a lender will place on the finished property.

Richard CrabbCEO, ASPIRE Property Advisor NetworkVice Chair, Property Investment Professionals of Australia6 min read

From the 1st of July 2027, an eligible new dwelling will carry a tax advantage over established residential property. Rental losses on established residential property bought after 7.30pm AEST on the 12th of May 2026 can then be offset only against residential income and gains. An eligible new dwelling can still be negatively geared against salary and other income, and it keeps the 50% capital gains tax discount.

Between contract and settlement, the investor carries builder risk along with the chance of a cost overrun, a late finish or a valuation below the price paid. Any one of them can cost more than the tax benefit returns.

Tax is one factor in a new-build decision

Whether a property counts as new is a legal test. The test is set out in the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026, introduced on the 14th of October 2026. As at the 7th of November 2026 it had passed the House of Representatives and was before the Senate. A property that passes the test can cost less to hold after tax than an established residential property bought after the May 2026 cut-off. It does nothing for the location, the land content, the number of similar homes competing for tenants or the price a later buyer will pay.

Survey respondents appear cautious about new builds. In the 2026 PIPA Annual Investor Sentiment Survey, 4.8% of respondents said they were more willing to buy a new build because the tax benefits remain. By contrast, 50.7% said they would continue to prefer established property. Investing in a new build: the strategy has to come first makes the case for settling the location and the asset first. New or established compares the two as investments.

A fair counterpoint is that the tax benefit can be large enough to absorb some delay or a cost overrun. Sometimes it is. To find out, set the after-tax benefit for that property under the new negative gearing rules against the cost of a longer build or a lower valuation. The timeline below shows where each risk arises between contract and settlement.

Where each risk arises, from contract to settlement
  1. 1Before signing: builder riskLicence on the state register. Contracting company and record. Warranty insurance certificate.
  2. 2Signing the contract: contract riskProvisional sums itemised. Rise and fall clause capped. Sunset date and its terms.
  3. 3During construction: build time riskInterest on each progress payment. Room in the cash flow for delay.
  4. 4Completion and settlement: valuation riskLender values the finished home. Any shortfall is paid in cash. Loan reassessed at settlement.
Where the main risks arise between contract and settlement on a new-build purchase, and what to check at each point. Source: the contract, lending and insurance checks cited in the data sources, current at 07/11/2026.

Builder risk starts with financial strength

ASIC's statistics show that 3,472 construction companies entered external administration for the first time in the 2025-26 financial year, or 24.5% of all companies that did so. When a builder fails partway through a job, the owner usually pays more for a replacement builder. The loan and the land keep costing money through months of delay.

Start with the builder's licence on the state regulator's public register. Then ask how long the company has traded, how many homes it completes each year and how many sites it is running now. Visit homes it has finished in the last two years. Check which company will sign the contract, because a group can place its building work in an entity with few assets. A builder that has grown quickly on little capital, or that asks for payments ahead of the work completed, warrants closer questions.

Provisional sums decide the final cost

A fixed-price contract fixes the price of the work it describes. Items left as provisional sums or prime cost allowances are estimates, and the owner pays the actual cost. Site works, driveways, fencing, landscaping and floor coverings are common examples. A rise and fall clause goes further and allows the builder to pass on increases in labour and material costs during the build.

Cotality's Cordell Construction Cost Index rose 1.0% in the September quarter of 2026 and 3.2% over the year, and Cotality points to continued pressure on builders' already tight margins. A builder working on thin margins has more reason to recover costs through variations. Ask the builder to itemise each provisional sum and price it against current quotes, and to remove or cap any rise and fall clause.

Sunset clauses and the cost of delay

Every month between paying the deposit and receiving the first rent is a month of cost without income. With a house and land package, the investor usually settles the land first and then pays interest on each progress payment while the builder completes the house. For an off-the-plan apartment, the deposit stays tied up for the life of the project. Construction loan interest and the vacant land rules covers the tax treatment of interest during construction.

In New South Wales and Victoria, a developer cannot end a residential off-the-plan contract under a sunset clause without the buyer's written consent or a Supreme Court order. Queensland has applied a similar rule since the 22nd of November 2023 to off-the-plan contracts for land, though not apartments, with termination also allowed in other prescribed circumstances. These laws stop a developer cancelling to resell at a higher price, but the cost of a delay still sits with the buyer.

Valuation and lending at settlement

The buyer and the builder agree the contract price at signing. For an off-the-plan or single-contract purchase, the lender can only value the finished property, and it uses that valuation to set how much it will lend. If the valuation comes in under the price, the buyer funds the gap in cash. The risk is greatest where many similar homes are selling at once, and in markets that have softened since the buyer signed the contract.

Since the 1st of February 2026, APRA has capped new loans to borrowers with total debt of six times income or more at 20% of each lender's new lending. Owner-occupier and investor lending are measured separately, and loans to buy or build a new dwelling are excluded. The lender still assesses serviceability, and it can reassess the loan at settlement on the income, debts and interest rates of that time.

Home warranty insurance varies by state

New South Wales and Victoria require home warranty or domestic building insurance on residential building work over $20,000, and the rules in other states differ. In New South Wales the cover applies only in limited cases, such as the builder dying, disappearing or becoming insolvent. The scheme caps the amounts it pays, and owners must claim within set periods.

Victoria changed its scheme for contracts signed from the 1st of July 2026. Owners can now claim through the Building and Plumbing Commission when a building problem is first identified, without waiting for the builder to fail. Neither state's scheme covers new apartments in buildings of more than three storeys, which takes in many off-the-plan purchases.

Ask for the certificate of insurance before paying any deposit, and check what the cover in your state will pay for. The pitfalls worth avoiding with a new-build investment sets out other traps in this part of the market.

Steps before signing a new-build contract

The insolvency, construction cost and lending evidence above points to six steps to take before any weight goes on the tax treatment.

  1. Have a solicitor or conveyancer review the provisional sums, any rise and fall clause and the sunset terms before you sign.
  2. Confirm your borrowing capacity with a mortgage broker, including how lenders value new stock at completion and treat a pre-approval that expires before settlement.
  3. Base your view of the location on professional research into the macro and micro drivers that decide how it performs, such as supply, rents, vacancy, employment and population.
  4. Model the holding cost if the build runs long and the valuation at completion falls short of the contract price.
  5. Understand how the new dwelling definition and the negative gearing changes from the 1st of July 2027 apply to this property and to each asset you already hold. The negative gearing changes reach only established residential property bought after 7.30pm AEST on the 12th of May 2026.
  6. Build a clear picture of your current portfolio and test the purchase against the plan you have set for it.

Whether to buy a new build, and which one, is your decision. It is best made with an Accredited Advisor who knows your goals and plan, working alongside the licensed professionals your circumstances require.

Data sources

  • ASICInsolvency: ASIC insolvency statistics, Series 1 and 2, companies entering external administration for the first time, 2025-26 financial year, released the 2nd of November 2026 (data to the 18th of October 2026).
  • CotalityConstruction costs: Cotality Cordell Construction Cost Index, September quarter 2026, released the 21st of October 2026.
  • APRALending limits: APRA, debt-to-income limits, applying from the 1st of February 2026.
  • PIPAInvestor intentions: 2026 PIPA Annual Investor Sentiment Survey, August 2026, released the 11th of September 2026.
  • Sunset clausesConveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), Part 4 Division 10, section 66ZS; Sale of Land Act 1962 (Vic), sections 10A to 10E; Land Sales Act 1984 (Qld), as amended from the 22nd of November 2023.
  • Home warranty insuranceVictorian Government, contracts signed from the 1st of July 2026; Service NSW and SIRA, home building compensation cover and exemptions in New South Wales.
  • Australian Taxation OfficeTax measures: Australian Taxation Office, Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026; definition of a new residential dwelling, Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026, introduced the 14th of October 2026.

General information only, current at the 7th of November 2026. This article does not take into account any individual's objectives, financial situation or needs and does not constitute financial, credit, taxation or legal advice. ASPIRE Property Advisor Network supports independent accredited property advisors and does not provide taxation or financial product advice. Borrowing capacity should be confirmed with a mortgage broker, taxation positions with a registered tax agent and contract terms with a solicitor or conveyancer.

Speak with an advisor

Test the builder before you sign

ASPIRE Accredited Advisors hold the PIPA Qualified Property Investment Adviser qualification and work without conflicts of interest. They can test whether a new-build purchase fits your property strategy, from the location and the asset to the cost of a longer build.

Accredited Advisors follow the ASPIRE and PIPA Codes of Conduct, complete annual professional development and hold a real estate licence and professional indemnity insurance.

Be Connected With An Accredited Advisor